An old prescription, a new purse

Guyana has discovered a remarkably modern agricultural development strategy: rehabilitate sugar, diversify agriculture with “other crops”, improve drainage and irrigation, support farmers, and find markets for their produce. Modern, that is, if we overlook the fact that much of the prescription was already on the table as far back as 1897.
With sugar again on the ropes, the West India Royal Commission’s (WIRC) proposals from that year – after a two-year inquiry – have acquired an uncomfortable familiarity. We have changed the flag, the ownership of the estates, and the vocabulary of development, but the underlying challenge has proved considerably harder to change.
The Norman Commission, as the 1897 WIRC became known, confronted a sugar economy threatened by a decade of depressed prices from the competition of subsidised European beet sugar. It recognised that British Guiana’s leading plantations and factories had already made substantial technical improvements and factory rationalisation by halving their numbers. There was, of course, the reduction of the wages of workers at a time when indentured workers were still dominant and had been paid the same one-shilling daily since 1838. The wage was effectively decreased by increasing the “task” that had to be completed in a day.
Efficient production, however, could not guarantee survival under adverse global trading conditions under a free trade regime meant to benefit the colonial power, Britain. The Commission’s answer combined efforts to restore sugar’s profitability with land settlement, alternative agriculture, scientific instruction, and better access to markets.
For Guiana, the practical issue was especially plain: farmers needed usable land and reliable water management. A plot under floodwater was hardly an opportunity, and land preparation, drainage, and irrigation were seen as essential to the development of small farming and rice cultivation. Nearly 130 years later, we are still discussing how to keep fields productive, factories efficient, and rural communities economically secure. History has apparently been waiting patiently while we arranged another meeting.
There is, however, one enormous difference. Today, Guyana possesses an oil-funded capacity to invest on a scale unavailable to the old sugar colony. Petroleum revenues are helping finance the infrastructure through which the envisaged broader economy can develop. The opportunity presented is to turn income from beneath the seabed into productive assets above it.
The resemblance between the old prescription and the present programme is striking. Budget 2026 provides GY$113.2 billion for agriculture, including GY$81.9 billion for drainage and irrigation. It also supports other crops, agro-processing, cold storage, and fisheries. These are the practical foundations of diversification in keeping water under control, preserving what farmers produce, and getting it to customers.
Sugar itself receives GY$13.4 billion for modernisation, including mechanised harvesting and factory equipment. The government’s stated ambition is to transform GuySuCo into an agro-industrial hub for rural development. That is a consequential recognition that the corporation’s land, engineering capacity, and workforce must generate a wider range of economic activity.
This deserves support and not sniping from the side-lines, as the opposition is wont to do. Sugar communities cannot reasonably be told that generations of labour have become an accounting inconvenience. Rehabilitation should nevertheless produce measurable improvements in costs, output, and earnings. Oil money gives us room to make the transition properly, but it also makes it dangerously easy to postpone difficult decisions.
Diversification demands the same discipline. Announcing a new crop is the easy part, but the government has recognised that farmers need dependable buyers, affordable transport, processing facilities, financing, and timely technical assistance. But in a free-enterprise economy, the farmers will have to step up to the plate and modernise their operations.
The deepest irony is that oil now offers the means to carry through a programme first urged when sugar’s supremacy began to look precarious over a century ago. Farmers and agro-processors should use that opportunity to give rural Guyanese more choices, stronger businesses, and incomes that can survive changes in any single commodity market.
Otherwise, a future commission may recommend diversification all over again and discover that Guyana had both the prescription and the money.


Discover more from Guyana Times

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.