Not a blade of grass

Four weeks after signing an enhanced defence partnership with President Irfaan Ali, US Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth went to Caracas to announce joint training and intelligence sharing with Venezuela’s armed forces. Washington now has more access to Venezuelan Commanders and more leverage to discourage an escalation in their historical revanchism. The question for us is whether the US will use that leverage to uphold the judicial process that it has staunchly supported to date or try to persuade us to make a deal.
Our Government has given the right answer so far. After Reuters reported that then senior US official Jeremy Lewin had explored territorial talks and, according to sources, floated possible Venezuelan control over part of the Essequibo, the Foreign Affairs Ministry said the September meeting focused on the pending International Court of Justice ruling and reaffirming US support for the process. It said Washington had assured Guyana that its position remained unchanged. Foreign Minister Hugh Todd went further on November 20, categorically ruling out bilateral negotiations over the validity of the 1899 Arbitral Award.
The US Embassy in Georgetown reaffirmed support for the award that established the land boundary. However, it appeared to introduce two caveats when it also said the boundary should be respected unless a competent legal body sets a new one or it is changed “with the consent of both parties”. Those last words deserve attention since we have given no such consent. Yet Caracas has every incentive to keep the idea of a negotiated accommodation alive. On November 20, acting President Delcy Rodríguez again rejected both the 1899 award and the ICJ’s role in settling the controversy.
The military agreement changes the diplomacy around the case. The World Court, which is the “competent legal body” Venezuela agreed to as per the 1966 Geneva Agreement, will still decide the validity of the 1899 award on the record before it. Oral hearings ended on May 11, and the Court’s binding interim orders require Venezuela to refrain from altering the situation in the territory we administer. The immediate risk is that Caracas treats warmer ties with Washington as a chance to revive territorial talks while judgement is pending. We should use that time to secure specific commitments.
First, we must put the question directly to Washington by sending a diplomatic note asking the Secretary of State to say publicly that the United States expects both countries to observe the Court’s orders and comply with its judgement, and that it will neither sponsor nor press for territorial concessions. We must ask Washington to convey the same message directly to Caracas. In defence consultations, we should also seek written assurances that US training and intelligence cooperation with Venezuela will exclude activity directed against us and that information shared by the Guyana Defence Force will be protected.
Second, we should secure regional backing before judgement by asking CARICOM for a joint statement calling for compliance with the Court’s orders and eventual judgement. We should also brief Brazil and agree on whom to call and how to verify and contain any border incident. Brazil has historically staunchly sought to prevent Venezuelan troops from crossing its territory into Guyana.
Third, prepare for the day the ICJ judgement is delivered. We must brief our parliamentary parties, congressional leaders from both US parties, and key partners at the United Nations to seek commitments now to call for compliance once the decision is handed down. If Caracas acts in breach of an order or refuses to comply with the judgement, we should be ready to document the conduct and bring it promptly before the appropriate international bodies.
Washington’s new relationship with Caracas gives it an opportunity to do something for Guyana that another reassurance from the embassy cannot accomplish. It can tell Venezuelan leaders directly, before judgement, that military cooperation comes with an expectation of restraint and that the Court’s decision must be respected. That is what we should ask for now.


Discover more from Guyana Times

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

SHARE
Previous articleFrom dream to hardcopy