Whither constitutional change?

President Irfaan Ali’s call for the Constitution Reform Commission (CRC) to accelerate its work is as welcome as it is timely. He recently had cause to reject a suggestion for a constitutional amendment to address the impasse in GECOM because he has consistently advocated a holistic reappraisal of the entire Constitution rather than piecemeal interventions. Constitutions, by their very nature as the supreme law of the land controlling even the institutions of the State, must be seen as having continuity to ensure predictability. But while they are not to be changed capriciously, change they must – to address the new challenges and conditions facing the society by appropriately empowering the institutions of the State to confront those changes.
Parliament passed the enabling legislation for constitutional reform in November 2022 and a 21-member commission, chaired by former Chancellor Carl Singh, was sworn in in April 2024. The latest position is that written submissions remain open until December 31, 2026 only a month away with the intervening holiday hiatus.  While more than two years later the President has had to urge the Commission to begin community consultations simultaneously with its sittings, the chronology hardly suggests urgency.
Participation has also been gravely disappointing. Attorney General Anil Nandlall reported only six written submissions in September. A subsequent report puts the number at approximately 20 by October. These are figures for those stages, rather than a verified current total, but they expose the weakness of expecting public enthusiasm to materialise around an invitation to submit constitutional proposals.
The public cannot fairly be blamed for failing to respond in the language of constitutional lawyers. A citizen may understand that appointments remain deadlocked, that parliamentary scrutiny is inadequate or that communities have little influence over decisions affecting them, without knowing which constitutional article requires amendment. Converting those concerns into workable proposals is part of the Commission’s purpose.
The first requirement, therefore, is to take the process to the people immediately. Written submissions and public meetings should proceed together. Consultations across all 10 regions should have published dates, accessible venues and arrangements that allow hinterland communities, working people, young citizens and persons with disabilities to participate. Oral contributions should be recorded and accepted without requiring citizens first to produce a legal memorandum.
Public education must accompany that outreach. Short newspaper explanations, on-air discussions and clear online material should connect constitutional questions to everyday experience. How are public officials appointed? Who scrutinises expenditure? What protects judicial independence? How can citizens secure effective representation between elections? Such questions offer a more useful opening than a general invitation to redesign the supreme law.
Secondly, the Commission should publish a realistic work programme covering consultations, analysis, a draft report, public feedback and final recommendations. Monthly progress reports should identify what has been completed and explain delays. The CRC should explain if it is facing any personnel, funding or logistical challenges.
But thirdly and critically political parties that have been given mandates by their supporters  must put substantive proposals on the table. Government and Opposition alike should explain what powers they believe should be constrained, what institutions should be strengthened and what arrangements they would accept while occupying either side of the parliamentary chamber. Constitutional principles become considerably more credible when they survive a change of seats.
The agenda from public expressions is already substantial: electoral arrangements and GECOM, fundamental rights, judicial independence, public accountability, minority participation and local government. The Commission should organise these into focused working groups and identify areas of agreement early. Difficult disputes should receive dedicated attention rather than hold every other recommendation hostage.
Finally, Parliament needs its own timetable. Recommendations will have to pass through the Parliamentary Standing Committee for Constitutional Reform towards consideration by the National Assembly. A completed commission report must lead to published decisions, drafting and debate, with reasons given for proposals accepted or rejected.
Oil wealth has increased the resources available to the Guyanese State. It has also increased the importance of rules governing the exercise of State power. The President has supplied a welcome public push. The commission and Parliament must now turn that push into dates, participation, and decisions.


Discover more from Guyana Times

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.